Shelter Island Hotels

Home Port Bed & Breakfast

2500 Peconic Lane

Aunt Dot's Victorian Bed and Breakfast

9625 Main Rd.

Acorn Hollow B&B

2110 Oaklawn Ave.

Arbor View House Bed and Breakfast and Spa

8900 Main Road

Olde Country Inn

11 Stearns Point Road

Harvest Inn Bed & Breakfast

40300 Main Road

The Morning Glory Bed and Breakfast

912 Main Street

TOWNSEND MANOR INN

714 Main Street

Shorecrest Bed and Breakfast

54300 Route 48

Sunset Beach

35 Shore Road

Ruby's Cove Bed and Breakfast

151 Bay Ave

Stirling House

104 Bay Avenue

Harbor Knoll Bed and Breakfast

424 Fourth Street

Quintessentials Bed & Breakfast and Spa

8985 Main Road P.O. Box 574

Bartlett House Inn

503 Front Street

Arbor View House Bed and Breakfast and Spa

8900 Main Road
Inn located about 2 miles east of Greenport

By The Bluff Bed and Breakfast

5405 Rocky Point Road

The Inn at the Blue

7850 Main Rd

Silver Sands

The Pridwin

81 Shore Rd
Crescent Beach

One of the first things to figure out on any trip is where to lay your head. Whether you're looking to kick back in the lap of luxury or stretch a shoestring budget, cozy up somewhere sweet or party somewhere chic, the hotels of Shelter Island are ready to tuck you in and treat you right. You'll sleep well.

Boutique Hotels

Family Hotels

Bed & Breakfasts

Luxury Hotels